Enbridge's Revival of the Beverly Swamp Pipeline
The Enbridge Gas Dawn Parkway Expansion project from 2019 that was shelved is back now in 2026 with a new name: the Dawn Parkway System Renewal project, with the Kirkwall to Hamilton section still planned to run through the Beverly Swamp.
Hamilton 350 members attended the community “consultation” and information session hosted by Enbridge on August 25th to learn more about this iteration of the project and voice our opposition.
It’s clear that Enbridge is using a new spin to meet the trade-war moment of 2026 and mislead the public about what Enbridge Gas does: sell fracked gas coming overwhelmingly from the United States to Ontario households and businesses, and as a regulated monopoly across the entire province, make a lot of money doing it.
Beyond the ecological issues from construction of this pipeline through the Beverly Swamp, there are also significant concerns about this fossil fuel expansion being rebranded to avoid public opposition.
Expansion by another name
This “renewal” project will add a new 4-ft diameter fracked gas pipeline along a route which is already an Enbridge right of way. Despite being originally billed as an expansion project, and the diameter of the pipe at 4-ft being significantly larger than the pre-existing 26” pipelines, Enbridge staff at the community session jumped on any mention of expansion and insisted that this “maintenance” project would not increase capacity in the short term, offering no comment on any impact to future capacity.
Also missing from all the presentation slides is the broader context that the Dawn Parkway system ties into a broader system of fracked gas transmission that is deeply intertwined with the United States as a “diversification” feature rather than a bug for investors.
In communications to investors, Enbridge has not been shy about promoting a future of fossil fuel growth driven by data centres and coal-to-gas fossil fuel swaps that keep companies hooked up instead of electrifying their operations.
The word “climate” does not appear in any of Enbridge’s information about this or any other project. There is no public mention of greenhouse gas emissions relating to this project.
When asked directly about the emissions impact from this project, Enbridge engineering staff said that they don’t do “project-specific emissions modelling”, just an annual sustainability report. Their lead sustainability staffer present at the event refused to provide any information about emissions impact from the company’s expansion activities, claiming that they are “not good with numbers” but insisted that the company “remains committed to sustainability”.
Most alarmingly: multiple Enbridge staff openly scoffed at the mention of climate change.
Despite undeniable evidence that methane gas (widely known as “natural gas”) needs to be largely phased out by 2030 to avert global ecological and economic collapse in the near term, Enbridge staff state their company is essential to Canada and they plan to continue not just operating, but expanding in perpetuity.
Ontarians to pay the price
Enbridge staff stated when asked that they could not provide any estimate or ballpark range whatsoever for the anticipated cost of this project, and also stated that there was no staff member present for the public Q&A session with any knowledge of project finances. The last estimate in 2019 was $190 million dollars, and the costs have certainly increased since the pre-pandemic days.
They sought to mislead the public about Enbridge’s financial position and the fact that it is Ontario residents who will eventually foot the bill for this project, as with all of Enbridge’s projects.
When asked directly about cost, staff repeatedly said that they “will not know” until they apply to the Ontario Energy Board. While internally the company almost certainly knows what the anticipated costs are, the public will only find out after all the construction is completed in 2027-2028 and the costs will be tallied and added to their public information disclosure included in their next application to hike gas delivery charge rates in 2029. In Ontario, Enbridge Gas delivery rates paid monthly by every household and business hooked up to their distribution network are set to guarantee the company a roughly 9% return on equity annually.
Bizarrely, one member of the Enbridge staff claimed that gas distribution was “revenue neutral” and didn’t make money for the company. Again, publicly available documents with the Ontario Energy Board and a 2026 update to investors show gas distribution across North America makes Enbridge billions of dollars.
In communications to investors, they highlight that they are pursuing capital projects like this Dawn Parkway expansion because they are “equity self-funding” and aligned with governments pursuing “all-of-the-above” energy strategy, abandoning climate action and plans to phase out fossil fuels.
To try and suppress any concerns about undue price hikes, Enbridge staff at the public event routinely cited a “strong regulatory environment” in Ontario. When pressed about the fact that a former high-level Enbridge staffer working for Ontario’s Energy Minister took unprecedented measures to overturn the independent Ontario Energy Board regulator and extend highly lucrative ratepayer subsidies to Enbridge, an act demonstrating clear regulatory capture by the monopoly, they had no further comments.
What comes next?
Enbridge has not yet applied for a Leave to Construct (LTC) for this project with the Ontario Energy Board, Hamilton 350 will be closely monitoring this and send updates as they become available.
Public awareness and coverage of this project are minimal. Only one outlet, Flamborough Today, sent a reporter to cover the event.
In the piece, Hamilton Chamber of Commerce president Greg Dunnett parrots company misinformation that this project will build resiliency “in this global trade ware with the U.S.” and that doubling down on investments in multi-billion dollar monopoly Enbridge is “diversifying” Hamilton’s energy sources.
Enbridge Gas is a member company of the Hamilton Chamber of Commerce.
Take action!
Hamilton 350 will continue to oppose this pipeline.
Join our Fossil Fuel Resistance group to help us keep tabs on Enbridge here in Hamilton.
What you should know
The significance of the Beverly Swamp
- The Beverly Swamp spans three watersheds — Fairchild, Spencer and Bronte creeks — and offers one of the best and largest lowland swamp forest representations in south-central Ontario. It covers 2324 hectares, 920 of which are owned by the HCA.
- According to 2020 estimates, the pipeline’s eight-lane wide right-of-way – where most of the construction activity would take place – would run through 10 kilometres of Hamilton, damaging the part of the Beverly Swamp not owned by the HCA.
Why they want this pipeline
- To bridge the gap in energy needs until Doug Ford’s ill-conceived and outrageously expensive nuclear power plants are operational (likely decades away), Ford wants to expand the use of gas-fired power plants. And for this, he needs gas.
- This is projected to result in a 400% increase in greenhouse gases (GHGs) by 2030 over 2017 levels and an 800% increase by 2040.
The impact on your energy bill
- To pay for the pipeline, Enbridge Gas plans to increase rates for gas consumers throughout Ontario by $120 million.
Is it really needed?
- No. By expanding its energy conservation and efficiency programs Enbridge can avoid the need for additional fracked gas imports, reduce our energy bills, create jobs in thousands of Ontario communities and help Ontario achieve its 2030 climate target.
- Ontario could also keep its lights on at a lower cost and with much less pollution by restoring and expanding energy efficiency programs and by contracting for low-cost water power from Quebec.
For more details, see the Ontario Clean Air Alliance (OCAA)’s detailed assessment of this pipeline.
Counter disinformation
There's nothing "natural" about "natural" gas!
Enbridge and other companies that profit from producing, selling or using fossil fuels use the term “natural gas” repeatedly in an attempt to establish it in common parlance and make it seem innocuous. We prefer to use the term “fossil gas” to make it clear that it’s something that needs to be eliminated in order to help mitigate the climate emergency.
In the words of Enbridge Gas: “Natural gas is a naturally occurring gas mixture, consisting mainly of methane…”. Okay, so maybe by the strictest definition it is naturally occurring, but note the keyword “methane”. While carbon dioxide (CO2) is bad for the atmosphere, methane is far worse. According to the UN Environment Program:
“Methane is […] a powerful greenhouse gas. Over a 20-year period, it is 80 times more potent at warming than carbon dioxide. [It] has accounted for roughly 30 per cent of global warming since pre-industrial times and is proliferating faster than at any other time since record keeping began in the 1980s. […] even as carbon dioxide emissions decelerated during the pandemic-related lockdowns of 2020, atmospheric methane shot up.”
Check out this video from Environmental Defence for an overview of why we need to phase out fossil gas as an energy source.
Promote fuel-efficient appliances
Ban fossil fuel hook-ups in new builds
Hamilton 350 is working alongside other environmental organizations to promote the take-up of electrical appliances such as heat pumps and induction stoves over gas furnaces and gas stoves.
We believe that Hamilton City Council should join other jurisdictions in Canada and around the world in banning the implementation of fossil fuel hook-ups in new builds. For example:
- In Vancouver, all new and replacement heating and hot water systems must be zero emissions by 2025.
- In Quebec, it became illegal to replace existing furnaces with any sort of heating system powered by fossil fuels after December 2023.
Heat pumps: The smart way to heat and cool your home
From the Ontario Clean Air Alliance (OCAA): “Heat pump technology is the smart, modern way to heat and cool your home. Heat pumps move heat from the outside air or the ground to the inside of your home in winter and are three to four times more energy efficient than a gas furnace. In summer, they move heat out of your home and are up to twice as efficient as a conventional air conditioner. The result is that heat pumps use far less energy to heat and cool your home. And when heat pumps are powered by zero carbon electricity, they can massively reduce your home’s climate impact.”
How do they do that? See this article from The Guardian for an animated visual of how heat pumps work.
Factcheck: 18 misleading myths about heat pumps
Heat pumps now feature in most proposals for cutting greenhouse gas emissions to net-zero by mid-century in order to meet the globally agreed aim of avoiding dangerous climate change.
For example, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) says with high confidence that net-zero energy systems will include the electrification of heating “rely[ing] substantially on heat pumps” – with a possible exception only for extreme climates.
Heat pumps significantly cut greenhouse gas emissions from building heat and are the “central technology in the global transition to secure and sustainable heating”, according to the International Energy Agency (IEA).
Heat pumps are also a mature technology and are very popular in countries such as Norway, Sweden and Finland, where they are the dominant heating technology. For the first time in 2022, heat pumps outsold gas boilers in the US – and they continued to do so in 2023.
Yet, in major economies such as the UK and Germany, heat pumps are the subject of hostile and misleading reporting across many mainstream media outlets.
In this article, Carbon Brief factchecks 18 of the most common and persistent myths about heat pumps.